Julia Delbel
Julia is a writer at Talent Recap and hails from the Greater Toronto Area. She is currently pursuing a degree in Media Studies. When not sharing her latest reality TV hot takes she's likely enjoying a game night with friends, collecting enamel pins, or spending time with her cat, Zoey.
→ Recent Posts
| April 28, 2019 SIGN IN TO SAVE POST
ABCReading Time: 3 minutes
People have been talking about American Idol‘s Disney night all week. But the hottest topic of that conversation isn’t the amazing performances we saw, or Katy Perry’s amazing Ursula getup. Sunday night’s results re-fueled a long-standing Idol debate: is there some sort of racial bias involved with this show?
Sunday’s episode ended with the elimination of Dimitrius Graham and
Uché from the competition, with Alyssa Raghu joining them in the bottom 3. These three were among the bottom seven last week, but were each chosen by one of the judges to be saved and stay in the competition.
They were also three of the only three people of color left standing, with Dimitrius and Uché being the only two black contestants in the top 10, or to even make it to the live rounds. And this was something that did not go unnoticed by a lot of fans.
How American idol vote off both black people the same night? 😑
— Tayler (@tayfoe14) April 25, 2019https://twitter.com/queenofironyRN/status/1120166359277551616
While others simply rolled their eyes at the people upset by the results.
https://twitter.com/freddy25/status/1120377283389399041
https://twitter.com/_leahthomas13/status/1120147544691085314?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1120147544691085314&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.yahoo.com%2Fentertainment%2Fidol-so-snow-white-a-controversial-doubleelimination-on-american-idol-disney-night-034733164.html
One thing to note is that this isn’t the first time we’ve seen a scenario like this on Idol. Of the show’s previous 16 winners, 12 have been white. And it’s fairly common to see the bulk of the people of color to make it to the live rounds leave relatively early (like last season when we lost at least one person of color every week and the finale ended up consisting of – you guessed it – three white contestants.
#AmericanIdol voters: you can be black or you can be flamboyant but you can’t be both 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
— Bubby (@flyguy2snackz) April 22, 2019While I would guess most of the audience isn’t thinking directly about the races of the contestants when voting, there may be some implicit biases involved. While this can never be confirmed as RIGHT, it does make sense. While Idol isn’ on FOX anymore, ABC’s main demo tends to be a bit more on the conservative side, compared to, say, NBC where The Voice airs (though not without this sort of thing happening at times as well).
The bottom 3 are all people of color? (and clearly NOT the weakest singers) It’s not a coincidence!! I’m not trying to start anything but I can’t be the only one thinking this.. Also I’m salty AF that Uche went home.. 😭😭😭
— Kait (@KaitNicholexo) April 24, 2019It’s very unfortunate that we often lose talented people of color so early on this show like we did on Sunday night. Is it racism? Probably not explicitly, and it’s definitely not always the case. But when these sorts of scenarios happen this often, it seems very possible that there is some sort of internal bias going on. For some reason, a lot of American Idol‘s (predominantly white) audience seems to have an easier time connecting with and getting behind performers who…fit a certain mold.
How can this change? Will it ever change? Is there even anything that needs to change? Conversations like these can be difficult – even uncomfortable at times – but they’re certainly ones worth having. So please, share your thoughts on all of this in the comments below!
Let us know what you feel about this article
Tags American IdolncG1vNJzZmiskaGyr8DRnpqaqF6YvK57yKxkmqWVp7akrc1moJ2nnGKzoq%2FIp55mqpGYtrS5jJ%2BpqKVdnsG0ecCum6KdnpiycA%3D%3D